Blog

The Impact of Canada’s Regulatory Burden

The Impact of Canada’s Regulatory Burden
Profile photo of Gregory Cummings

Red TapeOn Monday, the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) unveiled the third edition of Canada’s Red Tape Report. It reveals the pecuniary impact of the various government regulations imposed on Canadian businesses. For the first time ever, it also compares the costs of Canada’s regulatory burden with those of the United States.

The direct costs to Canadian businesses are startling. At the same time, it is instructive to emphasize the indirect consequences of government regulations.

According to the study, which surveyed small businesses, the estimated cost of government regulations to Canadian businesses is approximately $31 billion per year. On a per-employee basis, this is considerably higher than in the United States. In order to put this in perspective, consider that $31 billion exceeds total annual GST revenues. It also constitutes all of the provincial deficits and half of the federal deficit for 2011-12.

Making matters worse, it is an underestimate. First of all, the study did not include publicly-traded firms, which face additional regulatory requirements, in its analysis. It also does not include the costs associated with government administration and lobbying. Regulations don’t write and enforce themselves, after all. Considering that the United States Federal Register published 77,250 pages of triple-column regulations in 2012, it appears that bureaucrats and lobbyists have no shortage of writing or enforcing to do.

In addition, the $31 billion figure does not include the opportunity cost of lost economic activity and productivity. This applies to bureaucrats who could otherwise be employed in the voluntary private sector. It also includes the time devoted to complying with regulatory requirements. For example, an average small business in Canada with four employees devotes more than 682 hours per year to regulatory compliance. This amounts to 91 work days per year for a single employee. Stated differently, it means that one out of only four employees will work exclusively on regulatory compliance from January until mid-May, every single year, on the business-owner’s dime. Were it not for this burden, what else could this employee accomplish during this time?

Alternatively, this is money that businesses could have re-invested in capital equipment or expansion, further increasing productivity.

There is also a predatory aspect to government regulations. This is because smaller businesses are impacted disproportionately. In fact, the annual regulation cost per employee for Canadian firms with fewer than five employees is $5,942. This is more than five times the cost faced by businesses with at least 100 employees, which benefit from economies of scale. This represents a barrier to entry for would-be competitors who lack sufficient capital to overcome a disproportionate regulatory burden. As a result, crony firms of the too-big-to-fail variety often utilize their connectedness with government to increase and complicate regulations in order to insulate themselves from competition.

Meanwhile, a revolving-door effect develops between government and crony business, as complicit government officials often receive lucrative job offers for their efforts while in office.

When contemplating government intervention in the economy, always consider that which is unseen. From the CFIB study:

Perhaps the most shocking indication that the impact of regulation should be a priority for both countries
comes from the following survey result: 31 per cent of business owners in Canada and 23 per cent of
business owners in the U.S. say that if they had known the burden of regulation, they may not have gone
into business. It is startling to think about the impact on our communities and living
standards if one-quarter to one-third of existing businesses disappeared. This begs another question: How
many businesses never start because of excessive regulations?

Click here to read Canada’s Red Tape Report.

Blog
Profile photo of Gregory Cummings
@gregorycummings

Gregory Cummings (@gregorycummings) is a Pharmacist and Certified Diabetes Educator. He has owned and operated his own retail pharmacy business since 2009. An alumnus of Dalhousie University in Halifax, Nova Scotia, Cummings received his bachelor's degree in pharmacy with distinction in 2008. He lives in Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario with his fiancee and daughter.

More in Blog

ハイカウンター_(2771179096)[1]

For Restaurants, Sweeping the Floor is Equivalent to Cooking Great Food

Ash NavabiOctober 13, 2017

Shooting War in North Korea? History says Yes.

Doug FrenchOctober 11, 2017
stephen-poloz1-300x225

Bank of Canada Raises Interest Rates… Again

Caleb McMillanSeptember 6, 2017

Free the Arctic!

Patrick BarronAugust 29, 2017
peso

Preposterous Bubble Predictions and the Madness of Crowds

Doug FrenchAugust 21, 2017
blowing-bubbles-300x255

The Bond Bubble

Caleb McMillanAugust 16, 2017
immigration

The Reason for Statist Immigration

Caleb McMillanAugust 15, 2017
bitcoin-dollars-300x200

Is Bitcoin a Bubble?

Caleb McMillanAugust 14, 2017

Why Obamacare Repeal Failed

Taylor LewisAugust 2, 2017