Blog

Increasing Number of Canadians Can’t Afford to Invest

Increasing Number of Canadians Can’t Afford to Invest
Profile photo of Dušan Petrovski

Yahoo Canada reports something that comes as no surprise at all to Austro-libertarians:

More Canadians say they simply can’t afford to invest, making it tougher to build a retirement nest eggs [sic.], according to a poll released on Tuesday by Scotiabank.

In the bank’s annual investment poll, 64 per cent of Canadians said affordability continues to be a high barrier to investing more — a trend that has been growing over the past couple of years — as the March 1 registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) deadline looms, up from 59 per cent in 2011.

As usual the problem, and thus the solution, is sought after in all the wrong places. The suggestion is that investments are too expensive in absolute, rather than relative terms:

“The key is to get a solid financial plan in place to help overcome affordability issues,” says Mike Henry, Scotiabank’s senior vice president and head of retail payments, deposits and lending.

“Austrian” insights suggest otherwise: taxes in all their various forms are too high, which results in an inability to save. Investment would not be too expensive if people had the money for it. Here’s what Henry Hazlitt had to say about the power of taxation concerning production and investment:

There is a still further factor which makes it improbable that the wealth created by government spending will fully compensate for the wealth destroyed by the taxes imposed to pay for that spending. It is not a simple question, as so often supposed, of taking something out of the nation’s right-hand pocket to put it into its left-hand pocket. … This is to talk as if the country were the same sort of unit of pooled resources as a huge corporation, and as if all that were involved were a mere bookkeeping transaction. The government spenders forget that they are taking the money from A in order to pay it to B. Or rather, they know this very well; but try to dilate upon all the benefits of the process to B, and the wonderful things he will have which he would not have had if the money had not been transferred to him, they forget the effects of the transaction on A. B is seen; A is forgotten. (Economics In One Lesson, pp. 24-25)

Who is “A” and who is “B”? “A” is the producer—the earner; while “B” is the consumer: here we have a re-distribution of incomes. “A” is the person who is being disabled to save his own earnings in order to invest. But it’s worse than that. The recipient of government’s spending of “A’s” money, “B,” does not save what he receives either, for the simple reason that there is not enough to pay left over after his immediate consumption. Furthermore, “B” is given a signal that he need not worry about saving and investment (i.e. the future), since there will always be more of “A’s” money forthcoming.

In our modern world there is never the same percentage of income tax levied on everybody. The great burden of income taxes is imposed on a minor percentage of the nation’s income; and these income taxes have to be supplemented by taxes of other kinds. These taxes inevitably affect the actions and incentives of those from whom they are taken. When a corporation loses a hundred cents of every dollar it loses, and is permitted to keep only 60 cents of every dollar it gains, and when it cannot offset its years of losses against its years of gains, or when it cannot do so adequately, its policies are affected. It does not expand its operations, or it expands only those attended with a minimum risk. People who recognize this situation are deterred from starting new enterprises. Thus old employers do not give more employment, or as much more as they might have, and others decide not to become employers at all. Improved machinery and better-equipped factories come into existence much more slowly than they otherwise would. The result in the long run is that consumers are prevented from getting better and cheaper products, and that real wages are held down. (Economics In One Lesson, pp. 25-26)

And low real wages make investment too expensive.

  • http://www.karatbarsgold.co.uk/ karatbars gold

    actually, not all people can afford to invest something for their future, however, those people that I know have arlready prepared themselves today like creating of Gold coins.

  • anup421

    Thanks for this very interesting and charm full article, but I want to advice electrical lighting
    Thank you very much

  • robirul2013

    well concept ,I agree with you.I think the majority of income taxes are given by people and best source, The taxes inevitably affect the actions and incentives of those from whom they are taken. When a corporation loses a hundred cents of every dollar it loses, and is permitted to keep only 60 cents of every dollar it gains. http://www.berkmans.com.au

  • richdad59

    Well one way that almost anyone can afford to start investing is to start buying silver. Silver has risen over 400% in the last ten years alone, and is still very affordable. Silver is the new gold. Just buying a silver round or silver bar every month might be the smartest thing that you've done in a long time. Silver will rise as weakened dollars fail! http://buysilvernow.net

Blog
Profile photo of Dušan Petrovski

Born in the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and exiled from Macedonia with his family in 2000, Dušan manages his family's wooden pallet recycling company and resides in St. Catharines, Ontario. Send him mail at dusanjordanpetrovski@gmail.com or "friend" him on Facebook.

More in Blog

blowing-bubbles-300x255

The Bond Bubble

Caleb McMillanAugust 16, 2017
immigration

The Reason for Statist Immigration

Caleb McMillanAugust 15, 2017
bitcoin-dollars-300x200

Is Bitcoin a Bubble?

Caleb McMillanAugust 14, 2017

Why Obamacare Repeal Failed

Taylor LewisAugust 2, 2017
Screen Shot 2017-07-25 at 12.27.53 PM

GDP, GPS, & Growth Without Well-Being

Caleb McMillanJuly 25, 2017

The Real EU Aim in Brexit Talks and Why It Will Fail

Patrick BarronJuly 19, 2017
boc-300x225

One Fundamental Problem with the Bank of Canada

Caleb McMillanJuly 13, 2017
stephen-poloz1-300x225

Bank of Canada Raises Rates for First Time in 7 Years

Caleb McMillanJuly 12, 2017
5362386184_dc9f15bb9c_b

Who to Blame for the Toronto Housing Bubble?

Caleb McMillanJuly 11, 2017