Harper’s War on Pot Growers

Harper’s War on Pot Growers
Profile photo of James E. Miller

Last fall, Health Canada announced the national government will be leaving the marijuana distribution business and privatizing the whole affair. For a conservative administration like Stephan Harper’s, this can be seen as a welcome step in taming Leviathan’s reach over the country. But as with any program that still resides fully within the grasp of the state, the result will be far from laissez faire. The federal government will still maintain authority to issue permits to pharmacies that wish to sell marijuana to prescribed patients. That will mean higher prices due to the decreased supply that unfettered competition would normally offset and licenses dispensed only to those firms willing to jump through bureaucratic hurdles. In other words, Ottawa, not consumers, still remains the dominating force within the medicinal marijuana business.

And it doesn’t stop there. Under a new proposal, private horticulture of marijuana would be legally forbidden. Like the issuing of dispensary licenses, the prohibition is being implemented to protect Canadians from the ominous threat of pot dealers. In an official statement, Health Canada announced the measure “will protect the health, safety and security of Canadians and their communities by eliminating the production of marihuana in homes.”

The underlying message is easy to spot: the people, in their infinite capacity to destroy their property, must be saved from themselves. That equates to the forceful removal of plants deemed harmful to personal health. The lowly peons are to be told they are not deserving of the full, unadulterated use of their bodies. But while humanity may be working toward its own destruction through the philosophies of statism and forceful egalitarianism, this head-first dive into societal collapse is still not an excuse to further undermine the rights of man.

As anyone with personal experience will attest to, marijuana is far from a dangerous substance. Its greatest enthusiasts, which are typically young males, might be profoundly indolent but they certainly aren’t out robbing convenience stores to get their fix. When’s the last time you heard of a stoner beating his wife to death? Though marijuana may be implicated in some crimes, in the vast majority of cases it’s typically found with alcohol or harder narcotics.

Harper’s proposal, should it go through, will only create a new class of criminals whose only transgression is growing a plant on their property. According to the Canadian government’s official newspaper, the Canada Gazette, home producers of marijuana can produce the substance for $1.80 a gram. Under the new ban, the cost would shoot up to $7.60 a gram to purchase at a pharmacy. For those in need of marijuana’s naturally remedial effects, the jump in cost would be too much of a burden to cease home cultivation. At the risk of a criminal sentence, home growers would likely continue to skirt the law for their own health.

As Craig Elder write in the Globe and Mail,

If the proposed medical marijuana legislation proceeds, thousands of medical marijuana patients will be forced by economic pressures to grow their marijuana illegally.

Even more sinister, the measure will likely provide a great tax windfall to local and provincial governments alike. As journalist John T. Flynn wrote at the time of the United States’ kibosh on its disastrous policy of liquor prohibition:

Salvation was in the air. Repeal, also, was in the air. Two weeks before, the lame-duck Congress had turned a somersault and voted the amendment to the Constitution ending Prohibition. The wets were making merry with applejack, bathtub gin and prohibition hooch. “Beer by Easter,” they cried. Forty-one legislatures were in session for the chance to approve the wet amendment and to slap taxes on beer and liquor to save their empty treasuries… The country, the states, the towns needed money – something to tax. And liquor was the richest target.

The idea that governments act out of pure benevolence is as naïve as the adolescent belief in the tooth fairy. By prohibiting the home-growing of marijuana, governmental entities all across the Great White North will have free reign to tax the sale of drug to fund their operations. Domestic cultivation is a great means to avoid the taxman. How the money grubbers in Ottawa kept their mitts off this easy source of revenue for so long is real wonder.

If the Harper administration was serious about privatization and increasing safety (governments never are), it would abolish state controls on not just marijuana but all narcotics. The unapologetic call for ending prohibition on drugs is simple in reasoning: human beings own their bodies and thus reserve the right to ingest whatever they please. Whether it be ham sandwiches, red wine, or cocaine, the natural right to one’s self is absolute. Denying this law is tantamount to nullifying someone’s humanity.

Often times, supporters of any state initiative which requires suppression through violence will declare the issue at hand “is much more complicated” than to be dismissed through a declaration of rights. But a drug prohibition isn’t a complicated matter. Either people own themselves and the consequences of their actions, or they don’t. No amount of sophistry can avoid this pure truth.

Philosophers will often speak of the good life as something to be obtained through social tranquility. The Harper administration claims to be cracking down on personal marijuana cultivation in order to promote safety and security. Yet there is literally no good that will come of this measure. To enforce the prohibition on domestic marijuana cultivation, jack-booted thugs called police officers will need to monitor the premises of every Canadian. Should they detect any traces of the plant, then what follows will be the typical police operation of breaking down doors and shoving little Johnny and grandma against the wall with the barrel of a gun- all to shut down an incredibly small-time farming operation.

The government’s new proposal to criminalize domestic cultivation of marijuana isn’t just misguided policy based on sanctimonious ethics, it is a clear attempt to create another state-directed industry. The beneficiaries will be the police, politically-connected marijuana dispensers, and criminals who peddle the drug on the street at an inflate price. The losers will be the rest of the country as their bodies and actions will continue to be viewed by the state as no different from that of a stock of farm animals.

As Ludwig von Mises wrote in his magnum opus Human Action:

Opium and morphine are certainly dangerous, habit-forming drugs. But once the principle is admitted that it is the duty of government to protect the individual against his own foolishness, no serious objections can be advanced against further encroachments.

  • norma

    Great article. I wonder what the Doctors of Canada think about their patients control and rights being ripped away like this. Indeed, what is next?, what food we eat?, already too much control over us. Have we forgotten we have power in numbers? Steven Harper ought to smoke a big fatty and lighten up for goodness sake. Does he not realize 'pharmacy dispensaries n'all', that he will be forcing some people to the streets?, safety indeed.
    This plant has been used medicinally for thousands of years, yet in this time has been tragically misjudged and scrutinized by ignorant politicians, monopolized by criminal undertones and belittled by too many others that quite simply, just do not understand its medicinal and therapeutic values.
    Food and Water are next if we continue to allow this bullying.
    Remember Bolivia.

  • jamie f

    awesome article, but wow im so sick of harper

  • Donna

    DECRIMINALIZE already…Knowing the way Harper seems to think, wouldn't he benefit from being the first to decriminalize Cannabis and Hemp? THE FIRST IN THE WORLD…This is really getting ridiculous…Things will only get worse…

  • Medical_pot_guy

    Good morning ! It makes me SICK to see how human nature is so far from civilization. It's OK to promote the possibility of blindness, depression, suicide, heart failure, inability to fight infections……..and DEATH !!!!! with a single PILL.
    While you all sit around looking at BIG PHARMA blind you, neuter you, rape and kill you, all us "POT HEADS" will have seen it coming.
    But don't worry sheeple, next in line are your veggies and fruits ! What will you say when the Establishment tells you they're BAD FOR YOU… Take a pill and chill…..
    Cannabis got me to stop 32 pills a day….. I was quadriplegic following cervical spine injury in 2005. I could NOT walk or hold anything in my hands for 4 years….until I got off pills and discovered POT.
    Put that up your pipe..pill poppers…

    • kyle

      its replaced over 600$ with of pills a month i had to take paid by the tax payers, i grow my pot with permission in a warehouse with a few other people which has fire and other monitoring with live guard …so i dont see why i cant just do that. I am not a health or fire risk to my neighbors and i am saving the tax payers 600$, if it goes commercial I need odsp to pick up my pot bill….as its cheaper to grow than buy

  • Diane

    Great article. If the new regulations go through, the opposite effect will happen: the safety of Canadians will decrease, not increase. Illegal grow ops will increase because of the increase in profits, based on increased marijuana market price.

  • Jerry

    Does that mean we'll have a marketing board for pot growers? Hmmm, just got rid of the Wheat Board. Do we just change the sign on the door?

Profile photo of James E. Miller

James E. Miller is editor-in-chief of Mises Canada and a regular contributor to the Mitrailleuse . Send him mail

More in Blog


Bank of Canada Raises Interest Rates… Again

Caleb McMillanSeptember 6, 2017

Free the Arctic!

Patrick BarronAugust 29, 2017

Preposterous Bubble Predictions and the Madness of Crowds

Doug FrenchAugust 21, 2017

The Bond Bubble

Caleb McMillanAugust 16, 2017

The Reason for Statist Immigration

Caleb McMillanAugust 15, 2017

Is Bitcoin a Bubble?

Caleb McMillanAugust 14, 2017

Why Obamacare Repeal Failed

Taylor LewisAugust 2, 2017
Screen Shot 2017-07-25 at 12.27.53 PM

GDP, GPS, & Growth Without Well-Being

Caleb McMillanJuly 25, 2017

The Real EU Aim in Brexit Talks and Why It Will Fail

Patrick BarronJuly 19, 2017