Articles

Boycott Black Friday?

Boycott Black Friday?
Profile photo of Art Carden

fridayReprinted from Mises.org

I’ve seen a couple of exhortations to boycott Black Friday. I completely agree with critics of the consumer economy that consumption does not create economic growth, there is far more to life than material consumption, holiday spending has gotten excessive, etc., etc. Still, some are calling for boycotts of major retailers because they “ruin workers’ holidays.” The boycotters are off base for two reasons.

First, there’s a huge collective action problem here. If you’re not in line at Best Buy, that means more space for me. For the same reason competitive pressure makes cartels break down, a nationwide boycott isn’t likely to work. There are and have been exceptions, but I don’t expect this to be one of them.

Second, workplace disamenities will be reflected in wage rates. Suppose working all night on Thanksgiving is unattractive. If so, firms will have to pay a little more in order to attract workers to jobs where that is a possibility. I’m on board with those who want to be less consumption-focused, but even if we were to stage a successful boycott that made working at Wal-Mart, Target, Best Buy, and other places more comfortable, the reduced disamenity would ultimately manifest itself in lower wages. Just as people don’t live on bread alone, they are not compensated with wages alone. As David Henderson has said, you don’t help people by taking away from them the choices they actually make. You help by giving them more options. The new options for workers won’t come from the fact that you are avoiding the mall per se; they will come from the fact that your savings can be re-deployed in other productive enterprises.

I don’t plan to buy anything tomorrow, but it won’t be because I’m trying to make a social statement. There are a lot of great reasons to avoid the hustle and bustle of malls and shopping centers on Black Friday. “Helping workers” probably isn’t one of them.

Articles
Profile photo of Art Carden

Art Carden is assistant professor of economics and business at Rhodes College in Memphis, Tennessee and an adjunct fellow with the Oakland, California–based Independent Institute. He was a summer research fellow at the Ludwig von Mises Institute in 2003 and a visiting research fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research. His research papers can be found on his Social Science Research Network author page and on his website. He is also a regular contributor to Forbes.com, Division of Labour, and The Beacon.

More in Articles

factory

Fossil Fuels Are a Blessing to Humanity

Robert P. MurphyJuly 18, 2018
bastiat-300x274

Happy 217th Birthday to French classical liberal economist Frederic Bastiat!

Mark J. PerryJuly 17, 2018
illegal-immigration-300x276

Just Give Them Water Filters And Whatnot

Art CardenJuly 16, 2018
washington_dc

The Fight for Liberty and the Beltway Barbarians

Murray N. RothbardJuly 13, 2018
KarlMarx_Tomb

What A Divided Berlin Still Teaches Us Today

Hans-Hermann HoppeJuly 12, 2018
market

Subjective Value Is not Arbitrary Value

Frank ShostakJuly 11, 2018
factory-300x200

Böhm-Bawerk vs. the Neoclassical School

Jesus Huerta de SotoJuly 10, 2018
Congress-2-300x2251

Google Should Tell Congress to Mind Its Own Business

John TamnyJuly 9, 2018
Quebec-student-protest-300x200

The Ethics of Boycotts

Murray N. RothbardJuly 6, 2018