Articles

Airline De-Regulation, United Airlines, and YouTube

Airline De-Regulation, United Airlines, and YouTube
Profile photo of Gary North

airlinesReprinted from GaryNorth.com

The American airline industry was de-regulated in 1978 under President Carter, not Reagan.

This forced airlines to change. From this time on, they had to meet customer demand. They were no longer protected by federal law against low-cost fares. The corporate culture of the airlines could not adjust.

There was an exception: Southwest Airlines. It had its origin inside Texas, outside of federal price regulations in its early days. Its routes never crossed state lines, so it was not under the Civil Aeronautics Board’s rate price floors. When deregulation came in 1978, Southwest’s competitors went bankrupt, one by one. They had been designed in terms of federal regulation. They could not compete in the new price competitive environment. Southwest could.

POSTER CHILD OF REGULATION: UNITED AIRLINES

In 1970, United Airlines’ slogan was “Fly the Friendly Skies.” It was meaningless. Robert Poole wrote a classic essay that year for Reason on the need for the de-regulation of the airline industry. The title: “Fly the Frenzied Skies.” Read it here.

In 1979, I wrote an article on free market competition. I also selected another United Airlines’ pre-deregulation slogan: “You’re the Boss.” When United adopted that slogan, customers were not the bosses. Federal bureaucrats were. In 1979, that was no longer the case.

United never made the adjustment. UAL declared bankruptcy in 2002.

The company has received continuous coverage for this video. A passenger is being removed from the plane. He refused to comply when told to leave.

There were multiple videos recorded and posted. One or another video was picked up by newspapers and TV shows around the world. For examples, click here.

This led within hours to this spoof ad:

United Airlines’ official position, according to statements filed with the federal government, is that its seats are guaranteed.

It turns out that the now-notorious flight was not overbooked, as UAL had originally announced. The airline wanted to offer transportation to a flight crew for an associated regional airline. This saved UAL a four-hour rental car drive.

This lawyer says UAL broke the law.

Naturally, senior management apologized. This was after the videos started going viral. Too late.

This is old hat for United. There are several videos from the past on such treatment. Go here.

United became famous for this video, produced by a man whose guitar was destroyed by United. United refused to replace it. I have posted it before, but you may have missed it: “United Breaks Guitars.” It has had 17 million hits.

They begged him to take it down after a million hits. He refused. Then he did two follow-up videos.

UAL management keeps forgetting about smartphones and YouTube. They are not alone. Bureaucrats everywhere have yet to come to grips with smartphones and YouTube. They do things their way until they pull off a stunt like this.

Bureaucracies, both public and private, are no longer able to act with impunity. YouTube and smartphones have changed the rules.

The British navy has long been described as an institution designed by geniuses to be run by morons.

United Airlines’ senior management is not made up of geniuses. The employees act like morons.

CONCLUSIONS

The recent videos are a reminder of who is still the boss at United: customers.

The free market is alive and well. YouTube is an aspect of this. So are smartphones with video cameras. The decentralization of technology produces liberty. It also produces ways to get bureaucratic policies changed.

Articles
Profile photo of Gary North

Gary North is the author of Mises on Money. He is also the author of a free 20-volume series, An Economic Commentary on the Bible.

More in Articles

hospital-300x211

Mankiw vs. Rothbard on Tax Reform

Robert P. MurphyJuly 27, 2017
painting-1-300x198

Property Rights and “Human Rights”

Murray N. RothbardJuly 26, 2017
doctor

Health Costs Are Rising Because of Price Controls

Daniel J. MitchellJuly 25, 2017
eiffel

The West Is a Portable Idea, Not Blood and Soil

Jeffrey TuckerJuly 24, 2017
mises

Reflections on the Misesian Legacy in Economics

Israel KirznerJuly 21, 2017
market

Mises’s Vision of the Free Society

Thomas E. Woods Jr.July 20, 2017
picketty

Thomas Piketty on Inequality and Capital

Peter KleinJuly 19, 2017
lebanon

My Awesome and Cheap Medical Experience…in Lebanon

Bill FrezzaJuly 18, 2017
pinochet

General Augusto Pinochet Is Dead

George ReismanJuly 17, 2017